Helm’s Deep NDA Doom Party

The Helm’s Deep NDA (Beta Non-Disclosure Agreement) dropped today. I feel like less of an over-the-top LotRO critic after seeing the storm of negative posts in the Official NDA-Drop Discussion thread.

Turbine was thoughtful to post a list of quick links to updated class guides. I looked over the Rune-Keeper guide, which noted the new addition of ground-targeting to LotRO.

Beta players are also saying the Rune-Keeper is no longer a hybrid class. I loved the hybrid Rune-Keeper, and I actually did switch attunements (from DPS to healing) and save the group from a wipe a few times.

Anyway. Reading that LotRO beta discussion is like watching an angry mob beat a horse that is sick because it ate all the mob’s cookies.

So let’s go contrarian and think positive. It’s easier since I’ve stepped back and have nothing emotionally invested in LotRO anymore, but keep in mind I haven’t been in the beta or obsessing on this topic for months.

Positives for players:

  • I’ve seen a surprising number of random comments from players saying they couldn’t go back to LotRO because they looked at their skill bars and their eyes glazed over with pain and hopelessness, not joy. That problem might be solved.
  • Familiarity with skill trees for new players coming from other games.
  • Maybe this structuring can finally pave the way for another expansion class. People sometimes forget that devs are intelligent, creative artists and designers. They want to do new and different things too.
  • Better balance and more defined group roles using the tree model. Classes being able to do multiple roles for real, and balanced well to do them. There are a few good reasons why Turbine wants to restrict cross-pollinating in the tree.

Positives for Turbine:

  • Their players are really, really passionate about that game. I honestly haven’t seen that level of passion in a while, if ever.
  • These skill trees will be a boon to class development for years to come. The structure will be invaluable for the class devs to rein in the mess of complications and spend less time balancing roles while doing it better.
  • Monetizing the new system with the store. I can’t believe Turbine did all this work without a plan to sell scrolls or perks for convenience and/or advantage in the new system. This is something no one is talking about.*
  • Furious news travels far and wide, and there are far more former LotRO players than current LotRO players who are upset. It’s possible the negatives and positives could be closer to positive than current players think.

*Actually, I’ve finally seen someone mention this, the Storm King, a member of the 2013 player council says: “If you want to make a small mod to your current build, you are out of luck. You will have to reclick an entire tree, if you want to make a single change to your build. And you will either have to overwrite your current build, or purchase another build tree. This was by design, so that your pain and inconvenience can be monetized. Huge suckfest.”

About Silverangel

https://kittykittyboomboom.wordpress.com/ View all posts by Silverangel

5 responses to “Helm’s Deep NDA Doom Party

  • Wilhelm Arcturus

    If they can come up with a system that doesn’t leave me starting yet another new character because I have no idea what all those buttons do, I will be happy. Because, as somebody who bought a lifetime subscription back at launch, I know I will be back.

    I know that it is too much to hope for, but I do wish that they would revamp the skill icons. All of those skill icons that we complained about back in 2007 that were too small and that in no way conveyed what the actual skill would do… they are all still there.

    As for monetizing it skill resets… no surprise there for me really. I wish I could quantify and graph the level and invasiveness of the monetization in LOTRO, as I am sure it would be an ever rising slope.

  • Jackie

    Well there you go. 🙂 You’re a part of that target demographic. The Warden was totally boggling for me going back to Rohan, for sure. I tanked for the kin with my Warden in Rohan, but overall I just wasn’t motivated to perform at a very high level with any class. I’d rather invest the time in playing something different. Good point about the icons. With less of them on the bars, maybe they could give some thought to making them bigger and clearer.

  • commenter formerly called wumpus

    ” so that your pain and inconvenience can be monetized. ”

    Remember, this is the goal every time a f2p game suggests that they are selling “convenience” (although usually they are selling a way around a grind). How I miss the early f2p days of DDO when all they were selling were modules for the game (plus a few things that unfortunately drove Jackie away).

  • Jackie

    F2P MMOs are a fascinating study in psychological manipulation. There are words for different ways of coercing people into giving you their money.

  • The Patcher of Sauron | The Ancient Gaming Noob

    […] want to play the game, not decipher whether or not a 1% change in something has any meaning, so the potential positives of going this route are a bit lost on […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: